Tuesday, 15 November 2011
1Q84: Books 1 and 2 - Haruki Murakami
That brief paragraph doesn't even begin to describe this book. Murakami's strength is surrealism and I think he surpassed himself here. Alternate worlds and mysterious figures are actually nothing new to him. Although some of his other books have been slightly more bizarre this really was something else. The surrealism started early with Aomame discovering that she was ignorant of some parts of recent history. Things that she is 100% sure she would have noticed. It's relatively mild at first though and picks up pace later on in the book.
As I said this isn't exactly new for Murakami. By book 2 however, it gets darker. I have read all of Murakami's books and never before have I sat on the edge as I waited to see what happens next. There is one chapter that this was particularly so. Of course the chapters alternate between Aomame and Tengo so I had to wait a whole other chapter to find out what happens. I have never had that experience when reading one of his books. It's the kind of thing that would make you stay up to the early hours just to get to the end.
One Critcisim of Murakami I have frequently seen is the slow pace of his books. I actually like that about them and I never feel that not much is happening. Instead I take the time to enjoy the writing style. I felt that I could take my time and appreciate it. It can be refreshing when you come across a book and you actually enjoy the slow pace. 1Q84 gave the impression that it was going to be this way too and so after the first chapter I settled in to that expectation. Of course, as I have already said, that changed in book 2. Since it was unexpected I was completely blown away by it. It's mainly for this reason that I would say it has overtaken Norwegian Wood on my list of favourites.
Don't get me wrong I think the characters are truly stereotypical for him. His writing didn't change that much. They are fairly likable and average for the most part. Sure they excel in things but in terms of personality they are average and it's another thing that I like about them. Even the quirky characters have that feel of every day about them (even when they are not every day. Perhaps because the characters don't see anything unusual in themselves and think of themselves as average). It's not a criticism and it's another reason why I love his work. Again with this book there was one difference and that was my reaction to them. Perhaps because I was so caught up in the second book but I really wanted everything to go right for them. I felt very strongly about that.
I really don't want to say too much about what happens within the book in general as I don't want to spoil any surprises for the reader. My recommendation is that you read the book. If you are new to Murakami though I would read some of his others first. Not because I think it's necessary to understand 1Q84. Really, it's because I would hate for anyone to read it and love it and then be disappointed with his back list after reading such a good book.
Of course I have yet to read the third book and I am not sure when I will get to do that (I haven't even picked it up yet). I am a little curious as the third one was translated by someone else. I wonder if that will affect the style. Definitely a worry and something to look out for.
Which brings me to another worry. How is Murakami going to surpass himself with his next book? I really don't see how that would be possible. I wonder if he will have set the bar too high with this one (in my opinion I think Douglas Coupland did that with Jpod). It will interesting to find out.
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
I just read Norwegian Wood as my first Murakami and was totally enthralled by his storytelling. I picked it as my first because I had heard that it was more like a 'normal' story as opposed to his more surreal books. I'm not sure I can tolerate 'surrealism' but I so liked Norwegian Wood I'm willing to push my comfort zone. I just picked up Kafka on The Shore at a book sale on a recommendation from a friend. And have been dipping into his short stories in Blind Willow at the library. You're probably right about working up to IQ84 . . . we'll see how far I get with his early work. Great review!ReplyDelete
I think Book 3 is a little different in style but not hugely. I like the slower pace of this book - he builds up tension brilliantly.ReplyDelete
Thanks Trish, Norwegian would is definitely the most normal of his backlist. I would say his strangest is probably Hard-Boiled Wonderland and the End of the World. It's good though. Some people believe that Norwegian Wood is semi-autobiographical although he denies it. I'm not as big a fan of his short stories. Kafka On The Shore is another fantastic book. If I remember correctly it's fairly mild in terms of surrealism so you should be okay. Hope you enjoy it.ReplyDelete
Sam, I saw that you had read book 3. I haven't read your review for that one as I didn't want to spoil it. I did enjoy your review of the first two books. I agree he definitely builds up the tension well.
I loved Norwegian Wood, Kafka on the shore,Hard-Boiled Wonderland and Dance Dance Dance. I know a lot of ppl were disappointed with Dance... but not me.ReplyDelete
You are so right about Murakami's leisurely pace. It really gives one a chance to ease in and enjoy the slow unfolding of events and characters. I cant wait to get started on this one, especially after reading your excellent review.
Awww, thanks Che. I liked Dance Dance Dance too. It's only his short stories that disappointed me. Probably because they were over so quickly and I think Murakami is better suited to novels. Or maybe I am just greedy for his words. I really hope you enjoy the book. It has a slightly different feel to his other books but still with all the much loved characteristics.ReplyDelete
The only Murakami book I've read is Hard-Boiled Wonderland, and it was like nothing I read before! At the beginning it was quite hard to get into the story, but from the middle of it I just couldn't put it down! I ended up liking it a lot.ReplyDelete
I wrote a review on my blog, if you want to read it: http://fictionworms.wordpress.com/books/f-g-h-i-j/h/hard-boiled-wonderland-and-the-end-of-the-world/
Hard-Boiled Wonderland was the first book I read by Murakami too. Like you I had never read anything like it before. I promise to read your review as soon as I have more free time.ReplyDelete